Candid Candide

“I’ve decided to be healthy because it is good for my health.”

Voltaire

I am the kind of person who spends an awful lot of time thinking about goodness: what the correct course of action is, whether what was done was right, or even whether there could be something called “good” in the first place.  I don’t think having a set definition of goodness is as important, though, as having spent the time thinking about it.  In other words, it’s more important that we try to be better, than it is to know that we are always in the right.

When it comes to values, for instance, I don’t think of them as hard boundaries, things which we use to define us.  Instead I think of them as corrections, little questions we can ask ourselves in a situation to see if we’re living up to them.  “Do I have a full battery?” is something I tend to ask myself in the morning – and often, just after lunch, when the weight of food is trying to beckon me to sleep.  “Over-communicate” is something I try to think of every time I read an email – if I find myself not immediately answering a message, I think “is waiting really going to change my response?”

Candid Candide: or, A Pessimist’s Guide to Living a Good Life

François-Marie Arouet, better-known for his pen name Voltaire. 

Voltaire was a French writer known mostly for his biting wit.  He took on censorship, religious intolerance, rule by divine right, and a whole slew of other hot political topics of the day.  Our founding fathers took a lot of their messaging from Voltaire – specifically Voltaire’s ardent support for the freedom of speech.  But Voltaire is perhaps most famous for his novel Candide, which was itself a kind of retort to a growing philosophy at the time known as “optimism.”  The terms “optimist” and “pessimist” as we use them today come from the epic showdown that took place then, over a huge, meaningless tragedy that took the lives of up to 50,000 people.

“Optimism, n. The doctrine, or belief, that everything is beautiful, including what is ugly, everything good, especially the bad, and everything right that is wrong. It is held with the greatest tenacity by those most accustomed to the mischance of falling into adversity, and is most acceptably expounded with disproof – an intellectual disorder, yielding to no treatment but death. it is hereditary, but fortunately not contagious.”

“Pessimism, n. A philosophy forced upon the convictions of the observer by the disheartening prevalence of the optimist with his scarecrow hope and his unsightly smile.”

from Ambrose Bierce’s The Devil’s Dictionary

In 1755 there was an Earthquake in Lisbon, Portugal.  The earthquake was so large that it left damage all the way into Northern Africa, and a resulting tsunami reached all the way to the Caribbean.  In its aftermath, leaders everywhere were begged for an answer as to why such a terrible thing would happen.  They struggled to find the right message in the earthquake’s aftermath, but they tried to come up with a message of hope.  The two most famous affirming messages of the time came from Alexander Pope, a poet, and Gottfried Leibniz, a polymath.  “Whatever is, is right,” wrote Pope, while Leibniz wrote a long defense which gave us a quote I think you all may be familiar with: that despite the natural horrors found on Earth, “we live in the best of all possible worlds.”

Leibniz and Pope were trying to rectify the terrors of the world with the idea of a benevolent God.  The people affected by the tragedy looked to their religious leaders and asked “how could this happen?  How can God let these people die?”  Leibniz’s idea was that this world is the best there must be, because God can only create perfection, and since we’re all here witnessing this existence, it must be perfect.  Responses like these were using a budding philosophy at the time called “optimism,” trying to affirm the state of the world.  In fact, this is where we get our terms for “optimist” and “pessimist” from, as we use them today. Voltaire was the first named “philosophical pessimist” of the European world.

Left: Leibniz, cast in his best light. Every calculus student has probably cursed his name at some point. Historically, he has often been painted as a villain, especially as an aristocratic brat who terrorized Isaac Newton. Outside of his contributions in the mathematical field, I had always assumed he was a dopy nut, until my last year of college, when I discovered that he had made a few modest contributions to the world of philosophy.
Right: Alexander Pope, a poet who really wanted you to know it.

Voltaire was also deeply affected by the earthquake.  First he wrote a long poem more or less directly in response to Pope, a scathing song of rage and rebellion that I highly recommend if you’re looking for something to get you amped.  And then he penned a book in response to Leibniz, the book which spawned this training: Candide, or, Optimism.

In the book, the character Candide is meant to embody optimism – it is said that “his face is a reflection of his soul.”  He sees everything as it appears, and moves through the world with the grace of a deer who doesn’t know they’re being hunted.  The book is full of outlandish tragedy being heaped at the characters: Candide is thrown out of his homeland for flirting with the Baron’s daughter Cunegonde, sold into slavery, beaten, shipwrecked, and at one point he even endures an earthquake.  And all along he has his trusty mentor Pangloss. Throughout the book, Pangloss and Candide try to philosophize the things they see around them, looking for the meaning behind what they see.  At the end of these ponderings, Pangloss always reassures his student that it’s okay, because they live in the best of all possible worlds.  And then the next tragedy strikes.

From Chris Ware’s illustrations inside the Penguin Classics Deluxe Edition of Candide.

After nearly a hundred pages of death and turmoil and horror, Candide and Pangloss find themselves back in their homelands, reunited with their original aristocratic families.  Candide is unhappily married to Cunegonde, and after all the spoils he’s gained and lost over the course of the book, he is left only with a modest farm, an ugly wife, and horrible neighbors.  He has foolishly remained loyal to his optimism, however, until he happens one day upon a Turkish Muslim tending to a fruit tree.  Pangloss asks the man about some recent hangings, and the man replies “I know absolutely nothing of the events you describe; I assume as a matter of course that those who get involved in political affairs often come to a bad end.”  The Muslim invites Candide and Pangloss into his home, where he gives them candied fruits and pistachios, and has his children show off their perfumes.  Candide remarks that the man must be rich, and the man says “I have but twenty acres.”  Pangloss and Candide return home, and Candide just can’t quit thinking about how the Turkish man is so damn happy, despite spending most of his time just working his farm and peddling his wares with his kids.  Candide realizes that all of the thinking and philosophizing and wondering that he’s done in his life has never amounted to much of anything in the form of happiness.  Pangloss points out that all of the tragedy they’ve faced must have been necessary, because it paved the way to where they got.  And Candide responds “that is well said, but we must cultivate our garden.”

Amongst all the brutish satire and jabs that Voltaire threw at Optimists like Leibniz, the thing he is most remembered for is that line: “we must cultivate our garden.”  Some of the most popular decrees, moral codes and self-improvement strategies build up a system of bettering that often neglects the easiest thing we can do to get to our peaceful places: to tend to ourselves, and enjoy what we get.  Clean your room; brush your teeth; take a walk.  You can see how commencement speeches and the self-betterment category have started picking up on this, with things like McRaven’s “Make Your Bed” or Jordan Peterson’s “12 Rules for Life.”  But 250 years ago, one thoughtful satirist used that line of thinking to take on a powerful belief system that was gaining steam all over the European world.

The Core Values used at my work.

Which brings us to the Core Values held in my department at work.  Come to work every day with a full battery ready to have fun.  Own it with action and attitude.  Leave it better than you found it.  None of these values are Big Ideas, none of them are hard to come by.  But to really be able to do them, you must first tend to your garden, or else you will always feel a little bit of setback.  Self-care is a necessity for awareness, and that doesn’t just mean personal health – it means making sure that your most basic responsibilities are dialed in.  You can’t have a meal plan if you haven’t stocked up on groceries.  You can’t always work out when you want to if you haven’t kept up on laundry.  And if the basic car maintenance isn’t up to speed, then it means you won’t be able to trust your car in the moments that you might need to.

So first, before we begin to worry over the Big Questions, we have to take care of the small things.  We have to tend to our gardens.